In Defense of the Mutant Oppression Metaphor (Part 4)

Dazzler threatened by police in front of anti-mutant protesters

Dazzler threatened by police in front of anti-mutant protesters

The following is the final in a series examining the validity of the X-Men’s mutant oppression metaphor. Read Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3 before proceeding.

I’ve previously discussed several ways mutants are persecuted in the Marvel Universe. Since the X-Men are superheroes, most of these systems of oppression tend to take the form of things that can be punched into submission. Unfortunately, most real world modes of oppression aren’t so easily overcome.

Real Oppression

Systemic oppression occurs when the established law, customs, and practices of a society systematically mistreat members of a particular group based solely on their inclusion in said group.

This oppression doesn’t make an exemption for physical prowess. Nightcrawler may be a badass on the battlefield but that doesn’t mean he — and those like him — don’t face discriminated in the job market, courtroom, and political arena based solely on his inclusion in the group.

William Striker saying "Human?! You dare call that... thing -- human?!?"

This is true oppression. It doesn’t matter that a few mutants can shoot lasers out of their eyes when so many other are denied access to gainful employment, government representation, and equal protection under the law.

There’s a reason why the only mutant politician I can name is closeted. Before his death, Leonard Gary was an extremely unimportant Representative (it took him eight years to get the floor) who went to great lengths to pass.Leonard "Lenny" Gary, a closeted mutant congressperson

Most mutants have neither the powers afforded a sitting congressperson nor the reality warping abilities that Gary used to help him pass.

Wolverine and Nightcrawler share a drink in Wolverine Vol 3#6Of course, individuals shouldn’t need to pass or stay closeted to enjoy the same rights, privileges, and protection afforded to those outside their group. That’s just more evidence of oppression.

In addition to a lack of economic and political opportunities, society also oppresses mutants through violence (both state-sanctioned and the illegal vigilante variety) .

I’ve already covered some of the more fantastical types of violence mutants face such as Sentinels, magic commandos, and government licensed super-humans along with some more mundane types of violence such as police brutality. (Yes, I realize how disturbing it is that police brutality can be described as “mundane.”)

Fabio from Uncanny X-Men #1 by Chris Bachalo

Police brutality (as well as inconsistent application of the law) serves another function of oppression beyond a simple physical assault. It isolates the group’s members by turning their putative protectors into violent aggressors.

A Note on Cultural Appropriation

I would be remiss if I presented this entire series without a brief note on cultural appropriation.

The mutant oppression metaphor has been strengthened by creators making parallels between Marvel’s mutants and real world oppressed groups. I don’t think that this is a bad thing when done allegorically with transparency and — most importantly — with respect.

anti-mutant protest lead by the Friends of Hummanity

Fiction can be a powerful tool in calling attention to real world social injustices. However, when done incorrectly, this can quickly turn into cultural appropriation.

how can mutants ever expect to be accepted if we keep hidin' behind masks an' facades?!

Xavier thinks Kurt should hide his mutational with an image inducer. Wolverine (and MLK) seem to disagree.

Cultural appropriation occurs when the group in power (i.e. the oppressors) steals a fragment of an oppressed group’s history or culture and strips it of its original context and meaning. This is not an acceptable practice.

Many of the forced analogies between Charles Xavier and Martin Luther King are blatant appropriation. Xavier is a terrible civil rights leader. His approach to civil rights (hiding and training child soldiers for combat) is absolutely nothing like MLK’s (living openly and nonviolent protesting).

Conclusion

Mutants are an oppressed people on Earth-616. This is apparent in the profound difference in the treatment of mutants compared to that of similarly powered individuals. The few mutants with enhanced combat capabilities tend to be the group’s extraordinary exceptions and do not reflect the normal experience of the group members. Even the power of these sparse individuals is relative and doesn’t change the general lack of economic and political opportunities or the lack of protection and stability afforded other members of society.

When done with transparency and respect, the systemic oppression that Marvel’s mutants face can — and often does — reflect some real world injustices faced by persecuted groups in a way that is culturally relevant and valuable.

Cyclops speaks out against mutant oppression

Advertisements

5 Responses to “In Defense of the Mutant Oppression Metaphor (Part 4)”


  1. 1 xmenxpert October 4, 2013 at 3:01 pm

    Hey! You linked to a piece I wrote! Sweet! t’s especially flattering because your pieces are so much better than mine.

    I think more X-Men stories need to focus on the more real-world discrimination mutants face. I actually really like what Bendis is doing for that very reason. He’s showing mutants facing discrimination. Grant Morrison did it a little bit during New X-Men, too, and other comics around that time were also showing some of that stuff.

    To me, the realistic socio-political stuff is so much more interesting than just yet another bunch of Sentinels, or yet another group like the Church of Humanity, or all that stuff.

    • 2 Daniel Amrhein October 11, 2013 at 1:20 pm

      Thanks! I love your “How Xavier Held Back Mutant Rights.” I’ve been looking for an excuses to link to it for month!

      I’m really digging Bendis’ run too (as you can probably tell from all the references to it in this series). He’s really doing a great job of addressing some sociopolitical issues in an exciting way without simply rehashing what came before.

  2. 3 juannavarro October 4, 2013 at 3:32 pm

    Loved these article by the way, it expresses many f the concern I’ve had with the series when it comes to presenting the idea of Mutants as minorities and the approaches about them. I put it up on the X-cast podcast group page for discussion… https://www.facebook.com/groups/4045322485/


  1. 1 Who Do the X-Men Represent? | Politics and Physics Trackback on October 6, 2013 at 12:12 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 4,641 other followers

Archives


%d bloggers like this: